Here's where to look in other cities. We compare where each neighbourhood sits within its own city: how dense, how central, how busy its streets are, the mix of cafés, bars and shops. That way a Hobart suburb can match a London one even though everything else differs.
4,733residents
465people / km²
55median age
top 43%for income in New York
top 35%for rents in New York
31%renting
21%flats & apartments
23%born abroad
20.4 kmto New York centre
1.9 kmto a train / metro
0.5 kmto the beach
221shops, cafés & places
Reading the matches. Each trait shows where City Island ranks in New York, then where the match ranks in its own city: “top 5%” means among the 5% of areas that fit the label best. Hover a trait to see which is which.
Know these places? Use 👍 / 👎 to say whether a match feels right. Votes feed into the rankings.
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Spacious top 1% · top 25%Mostly houses top 24% · top 23%Near the water 0.7 km · 0.7 kmVintage & books top 23% · top 4%Long-time owners top 18% · top 11%Retirees top 1% · top 25%
Beachside on the beach · on the beachSpacious top 1% · top 22%Few kids top 7% · top 3%Older crowd top 1% · top 1%Bars & pubs top 21% · top 1%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 1%Singles & couples top 8% · top 6%Near the water 0.7 km · 0.7 kmIndependent shops top 14% · top 4%Retirees top 1% · top 1%Parks & outdoors top 11% · top 14%Gyms & studios top 20% · top 6%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Mostly houses top 24% · top 23%Trades & industry top 7% · top 16%Vintage & books top 23% · top 19%Arts & culture top 4% · top 21%Gyms & studios top 20% · top 19%
Matched on density, street life and geography, plus census data on income, rents, age, housing type, renting vs owning, birthplace, languages, jobs and household size.
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Beachside on the beach · on the beachSpacious top 1% · top 4%Quiet streets top 7% · top 24%Older crowd top 1% · top 3%Mostly houses top 24% · top 23%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 24%Near the water 0.7 km · 0.2 kmIndependent shops top 14% · top 21%Retirees top 1% · top 5%Singles & couples top 8% · top 22%Arts & culture top 4% · top 13%Long-time owners top 18% · top 2%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 19%
Beachside on the beach · on the beachSpacious top 1% · top 5%Quiet streets top 7% · top 19%Older crowd top 1% · top 2%Few kids top 7% · top 18%Bars & pubs top 21% · top 18%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 14%Singles & couples top 8% · top 13%Retirees top 1% · top 3%Independent shops top 14% · top 19%Vintage & books top 23% · top 6%Long-time owners top 18% · top 10%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 17%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Beachside on the beach · on the beachOlder crowd top 1% · top 14%Restaurants top 1% · top 9%Vintage & books top 23% · top 19%Long-time owners top 18% · top 17%Arts & culture top 4% · top 19%Retirees top 1% · top 24%Gyms & studios top 20% · top 10%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Spacious top 1% · top 9%Mostly houses top 24% · top 21%Bars & pubs top 21% · top 13%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 19%Older crowd top 1% · top 22%Independent shops top 14% · top 20%Parks & outdoors top 11% · top 17%Long-time owners top 18% · top 19%Arts & culture top 4% · top 19%Retirees top 1% · top 20%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 9%Gyms & studios top 20% · top 21%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Beachside on the beach · on the beachQuiet streets top 7% · top 24%Older crowd top 1% · top 8%Few kids top 7% · top 24%Near the water 0.7 km · 0.7 kmIndependent shops top 14% · top 6%Arts & culture top 4% · top 15%Retirees top 1% · top 15%Parks & outdoors top 11% · top 17%Long-time owners top 18% · top 2%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 4%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Quiet streets top 7% · top 19%Mostly houses top 24% · top 10%Older crowd top 1% · top 10%Bars & pubs top 21% · top 5%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 17%Near the water 0.7 km · 0.4 kmLong-time owners top 18% · top 14%Retirees top 1% · top 19%Gyms & studios top 20% · top 12%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Beachside on the beach · on the beachFew kids top 7% · top 11%Older crowd top 1% · top 8%Bars & pubs top 21% · top 9%Restaurants top 1% · top 25%Singles & couples top 8% · top 16%Retirees top 1% · top 1%Independent shops top 14% · top 25%Long-time owners top 18% · top 23%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Spacious top 1% · top 10%Quiet streets top 7% · top 13%Mostly houses top 24% · top 8%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 2%Trades & industry top 7% · top 11%Older crowd top 1% · top 22%Vintage & books top 23% · top 7%Long-time owners top 18% · top 13%Retirees top 1% · top 21%
Matched on density, street life and geography, plus census data on income, rents, age, housing type, renting vs owning, birthplace, languages and household size.
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Beachside on the beach · on the beachMostly houses top 24% · top 18%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 9%Older crowd top 1% · top 16%Near the water 0.7 km · 0.7 kmIndependent shops top 14% · top 7%Arts & culture top 4% · top 3%Vintage & books top 23% · top 3%Retirees top 1% · top 19%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Beachside on the beach · on the beachSpacious top 1% · top 5%Older crowd top 1% · top 3%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 18%Restaurants top 1% · top 14%Independent shops top 14% · top 3%Singles & couples top 8% · top 14%Near the water 0.7 km · 0.8 kmRetirees top 1% · top 7%Arts & culture top 4% · top 17%Gyms & studios top 20% · top 14%
Beachside on the beach · on the beachSpacious top 1% · top 3%Quiet streets top 7% · top 3%Café culture top 14% · top 7%Mostly houses top 24% · top 19%Older crowd top 1% · top 13%Restaurants top 1% · top 18%Singles & couples top 8% · top 11%Gyms & studios top 20% · top 18%
Matched on density, street life and geography, plus census data on income, rents, age, housing type, renting vs owning, birthplace, languages, jobs and household size.
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Spacious top 1% · top 4%Quiet streets top 7% · top 2%Older crowd top 1% · top 1%Few kids top 7% · top 12%Mostly houses top 24% · top 15%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 1%Independent shops top 14% · top 2%Retirees top 1% · top 5%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 14%Gyms & studios top 20% · top 1%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Mostly houses top 24% · top 15%Bars & pubs top 21% · top 17%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 20%Restaurants top 1% · top 7%Vintage & books top 23% · top 15%Parks & outdoors top 11% · top 18%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 12%Gyms & studios top 20% · top 7%
Matched on density, street life and geography, plus census data on age, housing type, renting vs owning, birthplace, languages, jobs and household size.
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Spacious top 1% · top 16%Quiet streets top 7% · top 13%Few kids top 7% · top 5%Mostly houses top 24% · top 21%Bars & pubs top 21% · top 11%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 14%Singles & couples top 8% · top 8%Retirees top 1% · top 3%Independent shops top 14% · top 20%Arts & culture top 4% · top 5%Long-time owners top 18% · top 4%Parks & outdoors top 11% · top 21%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 20%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Mostly houses top 24% · top 13%Bars & pubs top 21% · top 17%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 23%Few kids top 7% · top 23%Restaurants top 1% · top 13%Independent shops top 14% · top 1%Retirees top 1% · top 12%Parks & outdoors top 11% · top 24%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Spacious top 1% · top 12%Quiet streets top 7% · top 7%Bars & pubs top 21% · top 1%Few kids top 7% · top 21%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 6%Café culture top 14% · top 22%Restaurants top 1% · top 1%Independent shops top 14% · top 2%Arts & culture top 4% · top 7%Parks & outdoors top 11% · top 1%Retirees top 1% · top 12%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 5%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Beachside on the beach · on the beachFew kids top 7% · top 2%Bars & pubs top 21% · top 8%Independent shops top 14% · top 9%Retirees top 1% · top 2%Arts & culture top 4% · top 8%Parks & outdoors top 11% · top 16%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 6%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Spacious top 1% · top 6%Restaurants top 1% · top 6%Independent shops top 14% · top 15%Arts & culture top 4% · top 4%Retirees top 1% · top 9%Parks & outdoors top 11% · top 15%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 1%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Quiet streets top 7% · top 18%Café culture top 14% · top 17%Few kids top 7% · top 19%Restaurants top 1% · top 5%Retirees top 1% · top 4%Parks & outdoors top 11% · top 2%Arts & culture top 4% · top 20%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 9%Gyms & studios top 20% · top 19%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Spacious top 1% · top 19%Quiet streets top 7% · top 3%Café culture top 14% · top 1%Bars & pubs top 21% · top 20%Restaurants top 1% · top 14%Arts & culture top 4% · top 3%Parks & outdoors top 11% · top 12%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 5%Gyms & studios top 20% · top 4%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Spacious top 1% · top 24%Few kids top 7% · top 5%Café culture top 14% · top 18%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 18%Arts & culture top 4% · top 1%Retirees top 1% · top 19%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 10%Gyms & studios top 20% · top 2%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Spacious top 1% · top 12%Quiet streets top 7% · top 24%Few kids top 7% · top 20%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 4%Independent shops top 14% · top 1%Arts & culture top 4% · top 1%Vintage & books top 23% · top 4%Retirees top 1% · top 24%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Spacious top 1% · top 21%Quiet streets top 7% · top 21%Bars & pubs top 21% · top 12%Restaurants top 1% · top 16%Near the water 0.7 km · 0.4 kmRetirees top 1% · top 3%Parks & outdoors top 11% · top 8%Arts & culture top 4% · top 23%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 18%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Spacious top 1% · top 10%Quiet streets top 7% · top 8%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 18%Café culture top 14% · top 23%Bars & pubs top 21% · top 23%Parks & outdoors top 11% · top 2%Arts & culture top 4% · top 13%Retirees top 1% · top 18%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Spacious top 1% · top 19%Café culture top 14% · top 8%Few kids top 7% · top 15%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 21%Independent shops top 14% · top 11%Vintage & books top 23% · top 8%Retirees top 1% · top 14%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 16%
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Quiet streets top 7% · top 14%Independent shops top 14% · top 22%Vintage & books top 23% · top 13%Parks & outdoors top 11% · top 8%Sights & attractions top 19% · top 1%
Matched on density, street life and geography, plus census data on income, rents, age, renting vs owning, birthplace, languages, jobs and household size.
No close equivalent here. This is the nearest we found.
Beachside on the beach · on the beachFew kids top 7% · top 13%Bars & pubs top 21% · top 9%Older crowd top 1% · top 12%Mostly Aussie-born top 22% · top 1%Restaurants top 1% · top 1%Café culture top 14% · top 25%Independent shops top 14% · top 1%Singles & couples top 8% · top 17%Long-time owners top 18% · top 6%Retirees top 1% · top 18%
Scores are 0–100. Every match uses Overture Maps places, population density and geography, plus whatever census data both countries publish (see each section). All are adjusted by visitor votes each time the data is refreshed.